PROTOCOLS
An annual review makes a subtle promise: that when we return, we will be able to say what has changed.
For eight editions, the Rule of Law Development Foundation has kept that question before those of us entrusted with the administration of criminal justice. Sustaining that conversation requires effort, conviction and a belief that, through honest examination, we can make the system work better for the people it serves.
It is in that spirit that I bring the warm greetings of the Nigerian Bar Association and congratulate the Foundation, its Founder and Coordinator, our distinguished past President, Mr Joseph Bodunrin Daudu, SAN, and the organising team on this eighth Annual Criminal Law Review Conference.
The Foundation has sustained a valuable space in which those who investigate crime, prosecute, defend, adjudicate and administer corrections can examine their work together. Its attention to matters such as confessional statements, correctional conditions and criminal justice financing brings the discussion to the points at which legal principle meets institutional practice.
That is an important contribution. Reform benefits from people who keep asking difficult questions after public attention has moved elsewhere.
I commend you for continuing to make room for the careful examination of a system whose decisions carry such profound consequences for human lives.
By bringing those responsible for different parts of the process into the same conversation, you help us understand how the work of each affects the whole.
This year’s theme, “The Future of the Nigerian Criminal Justice System: Institutional Synergy, Policy Reform and Judicial Readiness,” takes that conversation to another extremely important level: what must we do together to produce a better experience of justice?
As lawyers, we naturally review criminal justice through statutes, judgments and procedure. The people who encounter the system review it differently.
The victim asks: “Will what happened to me be properly investigated?”
The person in custody asks: “Am I so worthless that I have to endure such inhumane conditions? Have I been forgotten here?”
The defendant asks: “Will I get a fair hearing?”
And the person who has served a sentence asks: “What next for me? Will I have a chance to begin again?”
There is hardly a day that I do not thank God for the circumstances into which I was born. I did nothing to earn them. I chose neither my parents nor the opportunities they were able to give me.
When I heard about the children who died in NSCDC custody in Minna, I kept thinking: “There, but for the grace of God, go I -and so many of us.”
I hope we will keep that thought with us as we deliberate. The circumstances of our birth may shape our opportunities. They should never determine the measure of our dignity or the protection we receive under the law.
Those questions belong in every discussion we will have this week. They give each part of our theme its human meaning.
One important strength of this conference is its attention to the whole criminal justice process. The quality of a trial is affected by the quality of the investigation. The effectiveness of a court order depends on whether it is obeyed. And what happens after judgment matters both to the individual and to the safety of the community.
Each institution has its responsibilities. But the citizen experiences the consequences of how well—or how poorly—we work together.
A case file can move from one institution to another while the person whose liberty depends on it remains in the same place.
That, for me, captures the urgency of this year’s theme. It invites us to ask three questions.
First: what should institutional synergy achieve?
The Nigerian Correctional Service’s published figures for June this year showed that approximately 65 per cent of those in custody were awaiting trial—53,670 people out of a total custodial population of 82,195.
That figure cannot tell us the circumstances of every case. But it does tell us that the future of corrections is inseparable from the quality of investigations, the timeliness of legal advice, access to representation and the management of cases before our courts.
When a file is awaiting legal advice, who follows it up? When a defendant cannot be produced in court, who resolves the difficulty? When bail has been granted but the person remains in custody, who asks why?
These are practical questions. Their answers determine whether institutional cooperation has any meaning for the person waiting.
Second: what will make policy reform effective?
The proposed Administration of Criminal Justice Bill, 2026, places reform of our criminal procedure before the National Assembly once again.
This is an opportunity for careful professional engagement. We should examine what experience has taught us about the existing framework: what has worked, what requires amendment, and what has remained unfulfilled because the resources, training or accountability arrangements were inadequate.
For every new obligation, we should be able to identify who will perform it, with what resources, within what period, and how compliance will be assessed.
The continuing debate about confessional statements, which the Foundation has examined at previous conferences, illustrates why this matters. The experience of those who encounter the criminal justice system must inform how we assess existing safeguards and design further reforms.
Whatever procedural improvements we adopt, we must strengthen the capacity to investigate through reliable evidence and preserve effective safeguards against coercion. The credibility of a prosecution begins with how its evidence was obtained.
Third: what does judicial readiness require?
Electronic evidence, cybercrime and digital forensics already demand specialist understanding. The developing training collaboration between the National Judicial Institute and the Police recognises that need and is therefore welcome.
But a judge’s readiness cannot compensate for a poorly conducted investigation, an absent witness, an incomplete prosecution file or a defendant without competent representation.
Readiness must extend to everyone whose work makes a fair and timely hearing possible: investigators, prosecutors, defence counsel, registries and correctional officers. Each must be equipped to perform the task on which the next stage depends.
The Bar has responsibilities here too. We must prepare our cases diligently, resist needless delay, provide competent representation and uphold professional standards. Our claim to defend justice carries an obligation to examine our own contribution to its difficulties.
Our country needs an effective response to serious crime. Victims deserve investigations that lead somewhere. Communities deserve safety. Suspects and defendants deserve lawful treatment and fair trials. And those returning to society after serving their sentences deserve a genuine opportunity to rebuild their lives. These responsibilities must be pursued together.
I hope this conference will identify a few improvements that the institutions represented here can undertake together, with clear responsibilities and a means of reporting progress. Specifically: recommendations with an institution responsible for acting, a realistic period for implementation, and a means of establishing what has improved.
The Foundation has brought us together to review the system. May this eighth edition help us improve the experience of those who must rely upon it.
I wish the Foundation and all participants thoughtful and productive deliberations and a successful conference.
I began with the subtle promise of an annual review: that when we return, we should be able to say what has changed.
When we gather for the ninth review, I hope we will be able to point to people whose experience of justice has improved because of the work undertaken at this conference.
Thank you.
Oyinkansola Badejo-Okusanya, SAN FCIArb
President, Nigerian Bar Association


